How to manage and monitor your email marketing list

Article topics
- Why it’s so important to collect customer email addresses
- How to collect email addresses for your mailing list
- How to collect email addresses and stay compliant
- How to keep your email marketing list clean
- Email marketing lists: Frequently asked questions
When you run an eCommerce store, email marketing is a must.
You can use it to engage with prospective shoppers, make your most frequent customers feel special, and sell the right products to the right people.
However, there is a definitive skill to email marketing – it’s not just a case of adding a sign-up form to your homepage and waiting for the email addresses to roll in!
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll show you how to manage your email marketing list, from gathering subscribers to removing out-of-date contacts; all while staying compliant.

Email marketing has one of the best returns on investment around. For every £1 you spend, you can expect to receive £36 back.
Here are some other reasons why it’s so important to collect customer email addresses:
The data you hold is your own
While marketing platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn are great for engaging with customers, it’s important to remember that these are third-party platforms.
Let’s say you have 10,000 followers on your Facebook page, but your page is deleted due to circumstances beyond your control. This means you have to rebuild your page and regain your followers from scratch.
Conversely, you have complete control over your email list. Even if you replatform your website or change email provider, your mailing list stays with you.
Email collection doesn’t use third-party cookies
Third-party cookies are tracking files placed on your website by other websites. These are placed on your website visitors’ devices and used to track their behaviour, not just across your website, but across the internet.
Browsers like Firefox and Safari have blocked third-party cookies for security reasons, and in the EU, there are guidelines in development to allow people to set their cookie preferences directly in their browser, rather than on a site-by-site basis.
This means businesses need to rethink how they collect customer data on their websites.
The benefit of email marketing is that it doesn’t use third-party cookies, meaning you can advertise to customers without worrying about browser changes or data depreciation.
You can nurture customers until they’re ready to buy
Think of making a sale on your website like a funnel.
People start at the top of the funnel and gradually move down to the bottom, until they’re ready to make a purchase.
Email marketing is an effective way to keep customers in this funnel until they’re in the right place to buy. By engaging with them and sending them information about products they might be interested in, you can remind them how fantastic your brand is.
You can also use email marketing to re-engage with existing customers. The success rate of selling to a current customer is between 60% and 70%, while the success rate of selling to an entirely new customer is between 55% and 20%.
This makes email marketing a great way to tempt previous customers back to your store.
How to collect email addresses for your mailing list
Collecting email addresses may seem like a challenging task. However, get it right, and you’ve found an easy, hard-hitting, and cost-effective way to promote your business to customers.
Here are our top tips for encouraging customers to sign up:
Provide something of value

Web visitors value their personal data and will only offer it to you if they get something good in return. This means that if you want to encourage them to sign up for your mailing list, you’ve got to give them something valuable.
What you provide depends on your target audience and what you sell. For example, if you run an eCommerce store, you might offer a discount code or free delivery. If you operate in the B2B domain, you might offer an eBook or a whitepaper.
Will some people unsubscribe once they have received what you have to offer? Yes. But most people will stick around to hear what else you have to say.
Use pop-ups

When done right, pop-ups can be a great way to encourage people to sign up for your mailing list.
The average pop-up conversion rate is about 3%, but some pop-ups can achieve a conversion rate of 40% or higher. This means lots of potential new mailing list sign-ups.
Here’s how to make the most of pop-ups on your website:
- Avoid pop-ups that take over the entire screen. These pop-ups can annoy customers and even have a negative effect on your search engine rankings
- Use images to make your pop-up stand out
- Keep your sign-up form short and only collect the information you need
- Add a delay to your pop-up rather than making it appear straight away. This gives visitors time to take in your website
- Make it easy to exit the pop-up – either with a prominent close button or by allowing visitors to click out of the pop-up
- Regularly test your pop-ups and tweak them for optimal performance. It’s especially important to test how they look and function on mobile, as this can be significantly different than on desktop
Create high-quality content

It’s important to create engaging website content that resonates with the needs and wants of your target audience. You should take the same approach to your emails too.
Word-of-mouth advertising is a powerful thing. When you create email content that customers love, they’ll recommend your emails to their friends, and they’ll sign up too.
Give your readers a gentle nudge by asking them to share your content with other people.
Just ask!
One of the easiest ways to get new email subscribers? Ask your customers to sign up.
There are many different ways you can ask your customers for their email address. You can include a link to your form in your email signature, your invoices, and even at the end of any videos you create for your YouTube channel.
How to collect email addresses and stay compliant

If you have a mailing list for your business, you must gather your email addresses in line with national and international regulations.
The General Data Protection Regulation, or GDPR, was introduced across the EU in 2018. This law regulates data protection and privacy, with severe financial penalties for businesses that do not comply.
GDPR still applies to the UK, even though it is no longer an EU member state. The UK has adopted the UK GDPR, which is enforced by the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO). The UK GDPR was updated in February 2026 with the introduction of the Data (Use and Access) Act, or DUAA.
Domestic email addresses or email addresses that reveal a first name or last name are classed as ‘personal data’ under GDPR and must be handled with care. So joe.blogss@workplace.co.uk would be considered personal data, while info@workplace.co.uk would not be.
So, what do you need to bear in mind when collecting email addresses to stay compliant with GDPR?
Get consent from subscribers
It’s critical that everyone on your mailing list has given consent to be contacted. Here’s what you should do to ensure best practice:
- Implement a positive opt-in. This means customers have to tick a box to opt into your mailing list, rather than ticking a box to opt out. Pre-ticked boxes aren’t GDPR-compliant
- Use easy-to-understand language so customers don’t get confused
- Don’t make consent a precondition of service. For example, if someone has to sign up to your mailing list to buy from your site, this is a breach of GDPR
Keep records of who has signed up to your mailing list, when they consented, and how they signed up. That way, if there is an issue, you can prove that a person freely consented to be contacted.
Only ask for the data you need
The more data you collect, the more data you have responsibility for. With this in mind, it’s best to only ask for the information you need to send emails and segment campaigns.
The bare minimum is an active email address; however you may opt to personalise your emails by asking for a first name.
Let’s say you ask for a person’s date of birth so you can send them a treat or discount voucher on their birthday. While someone wouldn’t be personally identifiable by date of birth alone, this information could be combined with someone’s email address and name to identify an individual.
And given that some people use their date of birth in PIN codes and passwords, this information could be more revealing than you think.
If you do want to collect date of birth information for this purpose:
- Explain what the data will be used for
- Make sure it isn’t used for unrelated reasons
- Give people the option not to provide this data if they don’t want to
Under GDPR, people have the right to receive a copy of the personal data you have on file about them – this is known as a subject access request (SAR).
Only use data for the purpose it was specified
Customers should only be emailed information they have explicitly signed up to receive.
For example, let’s say that you’re working in partnership with another business, and they ask for your mailing list so they can send a message to your customers. This would be a breach of GDPR.
If you wanted the option to do this in the future, you would need to add this information to your privacy policy (more on that later). You’d also need to add an opt-in button to your sign-up form so customers could consent to their data being shared by third parties.
Honour all unsubscribes
All emails you send must state how a customer can unsubscribe from your mailing list.

The easiest way is to provide a link that they can click on to unsubscribe at the end of your email messages. Make the unsubscribe process as friction-free as possible; for example, people shouldn’t have to log into their online account or call a number to unsubscribe.
Remember that someone may consent to be contacted but may change their mind later on.
Note: If you send more than 5,000 emails a day to Google and Yahoo email addresses, one-click unsubscribes are mandatory.
Have a privacy policy in place
Having a privacy policy or notice on your website is best practice when it comes to GDPR. This shows web visitors:
- The type of personal data you collect
- What you do with this data
- Who you share information with
- How long you keep data before getting rid of it
You don’t have to hire a legal firm or a data privacy specialist to write a privacy notice. The ICO has a privacy policy template that you can adapt to your needs.
Link to your privacy policy anywhere that web visitors can sign up for your mailing list, as well as in the footer of your website.
How to keep your email marketing list clean

Your email marketing list will degrade over time. People may abandon email addresses or just disengage with your business as time passes. This may mean that some of the emails you send no longer get read.
Regularly cleaning out your email marketing list (also known as email hygiene) increases engagement, reduces costs, and makes sure you stay compliant with GDPR.
It also enhances your sender reputation. This is when your internet service provider (ISP) grades your business and the emails you send to determine whether you are trustworthy or not.
A high sender reputation means your emails are less likely to go to spam.
There are two key steps to carrying out an email cleanup:
Remove any incorrect and inaccurate emails

Some email marketing platforms track and mark inaccurate emails automatically and remove them from your email list.
If your email provider doesn’t do this, you can do it manually using email validation software.
Here are the different types of emails to look out for:
- Hard bounces: A hard bounce is a permanent failure to deliver an email. This could be because an email address no longer exists, is spelt incorrectly, or is blocked by a strict security filter
- Soft bounces: A soft bounce is a temporary failure to deliver an email. This could be because an email inbox is full, your email is too large, or the email server is temporarily offline. If you continue to get soft bounces, you may want to consider getting rid of them
- Role accounts: A role account email is a generic email address used by a group of people or a department rather than a person. These generally have lower engagement as these inboxes are often not monitored, or the messages received are not sent to the relevant people
- Spam traps: A spam trap is an email address intentionally set up to catch spammers. If you send an email to a spam trap, this may lead to your email address or even your entire email domain being blocklisted
Identify customers that aren’t engaging
Even if an email address is legitimate, it’s not necessarily a good thing for your mailing list. Customers who don’t open or engage with your emails can mean your sender reputation takes a hit.
A significant part of email hygiene is purging non-responsive email addresses from your mailing list.
The first step is to define what you would consider a ‘non-responsive’ customer.
For example, if you send regular emails, you might consider someone who hasn’t engaged with your content for three months as non-responsive. You might change your timescales to 12 months if you send emails less frequently.
The next step is to reach out to these unresponsive customers. You want them to start re-engaging with your content or encourage them to unsubscribe.

If you use an email marketing platform, you can send a series of automated messages to get them to respond – this is known as a ‘sunset flow.’ Alternatively, you can send a manual message.
If customers continually ignore your requests to re-engage or subscribe, you can take them off your list or send messages to them less frequently.
Email marketing lists: Frequently asked questions
I don’t sell to the EU or UK. Does GDPR still apply to me?
It’s important to remember that GDPR affects citizens rather than countries. So if your company is based in the US but you handle the data of EU and UK citizens, GDPR still applies.
Other countries and regions may have their own data collection and storage laws. For example, the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) which protects California residents. If you operate internationally, you will need to take these regulations into account.
Can I buy email marketing lists to get more subscribers?
We wouldn’t recommend doing this for two reasons.
First, the data in these email marketing lists ages very quickly. Email marketing databases degrade by about 22% each year as people change and abandon email addresses. This means you risk sending emails to out-of-date contacts.
Second, using email marketing lists means you’re sending emails to people who have not consented to be contacted, which is a breach of GDPR.
It’s always better to build your list organically, even though it may take a little longer.
How often should I clean my email marketing lists?
According to Mailgun, 27% of businesses clean their email lists at least once a month, while 16% carry out email hygiene quarterly.
While we recommend cleaning your email lists monthly or quarterly, it’s also good practice to review them on an ad hoc basis. For example, if:
- You notice issues, for example, lower click rates or an increase in spam reports
- You move to a new email marketing platform or customer relationship management (CRM) system
- You get an influx of new subscribers, for example, after a webinar or trade show
How can I stop bots from signing up to my mailing list?
It’s frustrating when bots sign up for your mailing lists, as it can mean reduced engagement. You can stop bots dead in their tracks by implementing the following two things:

First, a double opt-in. With a double opt-in, users need to confirm their email subscription after signing up. This means you know the email address is valid and that customers want to engage with your emails.

Second, use a CAPTCHA or RECAPTCHA, which helps differentiate between bots and humans.
Alternatively, you can use a honeypot on your email capture form. This is a hidden form field that only bots can see. If they tick the form, it’s proof that they’re not human, and they are blocked from subscribing.
Xigen: Your email marketing partner
Cultivating a well-maintained email marketing list doesn’t have to be tricky. Understand your target audience, focus on organic growth, and regularly review your email addresses to remove unresponsive customers.
If you need a little extra help getting your email marketing off the ground, we’re the experts. We specialise in email marketing, meaning we can develop and implement a strategy that delivers results.
Take the email marketing campaign we delivered for McCarthy Stone, a retirement home development company. Our team designed a campaign that led to a 46.7% email open rate, an 83.3% increase in web visits, and over 1,300 new leads.
Want the same results for your eCommerce store? Contact our team today, and let’s get started!